Watch
Listen
Click here to listen to the episode on our website
Read
How close are we to returning to the Dark Ages? We could be closer than you think.
The Dark Ages Return: A Literacy Crisis
Timothy S. Goeglein, writing in The Epoch Times, takes up the possibility of the United States, or even the whole globe, receding and regressing into a way of living that is archaic and not great. The Dark Ages were indeed dark. They were brutal. They came before the age of enlightenment, and there is a reason they were called the Dark Ages.
Goeglein says the slide is very possible, and he points to one thing: literacy. It's on the decline.
We've talked about people being biblically illiterate. We've talked about critical thinking being a thing of the past, with people absorbing whatever information is thrown at them and not thinking it through. Goeglein says we've gone beyond that. Students are walking into college and they can't read the syllabus, let alone do the work. They can't read a sentence, process it, think critically about it, and then either argue it or understand it.
Goeglein reports that college professors are coming to grips with the reality that entering students can't do even the most basic reading needed to compete, or even to start, the assignments they receive. One Pepperdine University professor put it this way: "It's not even an inability to critically think. It's an inability to read sentences."
Think about that. How are you in college?
The critical thinking alarm has been sounding since 2007 or 2008. This is something worse. A lot of what's going on is finally coming home to roost after twenty years of not educating people, and instead playing political games. Our education department is a joke, and that's why so many people have turned elsewhere.
So how do students who can't read end up accepted into college? It's a money grab. And the numbers show how far we've fallen:
- Nearly half of all Americans did not read a single book last year. Half.
- Americans aged 18 to 29, the college-age years when a person should be consuming and inquiring after knowledge, read on average just 5.8 books.
That's a far cry from what it used to be. James Marriott, author of a new book on the subject, says the ramifications for our society are alarming, to say the least.
Why Reading Is a Big Deal
What's the big deal about not reading? We can all see letters and sound out words, right? It goes deeper than that. Goeglein's article spells it out well: reading is what opens the mind. It exposes us to other thoughts and other ideas. As we absorb them, process them, and think them through critically, that is literally what expands our mind and our understanding. We have really, really moved away from that.
That's why this gets likened to the Dark Ages. Reading is what brought us out of the Dark Ages in the first place.
Gutenberg and the Printing Press
Go back to Gutenberg's printing press. It changed a lot for the history of humankind. Gutenberg began designing this monstrous wooden press in 1436, and it took him more than ten years before he was mass producing anything. In 1455 he printed the first Bible, the 42-Line Bible, which could then be sent out to anyone to read.
The great thing about having literature in your hand is that you can then teach other people how to read. The press got the thoughts and ideas of people onto paper and out to mass numbers of people, and things started to change. Ideas were talked about, discussed, learned, understood, and thought about critically. Anyone could learn to read and start reading books. That was big doins.
Back to Babel
Think about communication and you go back to the Tower of Babel. God confused the languages because man could do a whole lot of things that would lead to pride and lead to ignoring Him as the Creator God. The written word is without a doubt the magic elixir that makes societies stronger. A common language, in a written word that can be read at any time, makes a huge difference.
Use It or Lose It
They've even done medical studies showing that reading exercises your brain. It's like every other muscle: if you don't exercise it, if you don't use it, you lose it. Look at POWs and people who are isolated from others for long periods of time. What happens? They start going a little insane because they don't have that communication.
So if you learn everything by TikTok, and you make a FaceTime video to share, and we become a completely verbal society going forward, that's going to lead to more than a lack of critical thinking. It's going to lead to a lack of being able to achieve and a lack of being able to produce. That is going back to the Dark Ages.
Salvaged by God Deep Dive: Ephesians 4:11–14
There's something biblical about all this, because reading changes the mind. Look at a passage we've talked about over and over and over again, Ephesians 4, verses 11 through 14:
"And He gave some as apostles, some as prophets, some as evangelists, some as pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints for the work of the ministry and for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain the unity of the faith and the knowledge of the Son of God, to a mature man, to the measure of the stature which belongs to the fullness of Christ. As a result, we are no longer to be children, tossed here and there by waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by the trickery of people, by craftiness and deceitful scheming."
Three things stand out.
- People can say whatever they want to say. That's just a fact, and it made things really difficult for the early church. They didn't yet have the Word of God written out to compare against what people were telling them.
- From the very beginning, the gifts God gave the church put things in writing. God gave some to be prophets. What did the prophets do when they heard from God? They wrote it down. To some He gave apostles. What did the apostles do? They wrote down everything Jesus did and taught and everything they witnessed. Today we have pastors and teachers. What do pastors and teachers do? They write things down: lessons, messages, sermons.
- The written word is the defense against being tossed about. Paul says we're no longer to be children carried about by every wind of doctrine. To stand firm, you need something written to hold up against what people say.
There is something very spiritual about that written word. I really do believe that's why we saw such a change when things were mass produced and sent out to be read by the masses.
What Marriott Sees Coming
As Marriott points out in his book, as print dies we risk returning to chaos, tribalism, and the rage of the world that was historically known as the Dark Ages before widespread literacy.
Stay with this. People become targets for those who know how to manipulate and whip up outrage. It plays to the worst of our instincts and, as Marriott says, pits us against one another for self-interest rather than bringing us together for the common good. We're led by emotion rather than by "here's a fact, and here's the rationale behind the fact." We're guided by emotions and rage.
Doesn't that smack of social media? Everybody is hopping on, tiny little sound bites, very little in the way of actual facts and honest discussion and dialogue. People sound off out of their emotions, I've got to get this out, and attack each other. It is being reduced, absolutely, to rage and vitriol and hating one another. That's what's going on in the vast majority of it. Smartphones are definitely a factor, along with a handful of other things.
Gramster Rant: Staring Down the Barrel of an Illiterate Nation
Let's talk about what this does to the common good, because there are two things here that have to do with the Christian walk.
First, the common good is getting set aside for self-interest. We are staring down the barrel of socialism and communism, where they talk about the common good but it's all for their own self-interest. A lot of it comes from fake righteousness. They don't have any righteousness, so they've got to conjure something up, and they don't understand that they're leading this country into basically annihilation.
Second, look at what it does to the church. The church is not about self-interest. It's about the common good. And what is the common good? It's that we as sinners have the ability to be saved by the grace of God while we were yet sinners. All of us in that room are sinners. The common good is the salvation found in Jesus's perfect life, His sacrificial death, and His resurrection from the dead.
Now take the next step. You're in college and you can't read. What are they doing? Using audio recordings and having it pumped out so they can try to be a complete listening person. Look, I'm not talking about those with learning disabilities. I'm talking about how you get into a university in this condition. They're money hungry. They'll accept anybody at a certain point. If you can't read a sentence and you're in college, something is really wrong.
Then what about sharing the gospel? "Hey, I want you to read John chapter 3." "Hey, write God's Word on your heart." If all they can do is an audio Bible, that's better than nothing. But what does this do to the collective inside the church?
I'm here to tell you it should cause us to take seriously this idea of possibly going back to the Dark Ages, which is real. Then add the birth rate, and the differences between the boomers and the millennials and Gen Z, and all this other stuff. We have to trust the Spirit of God to break through when we share the gospel. I shouldn't even say "now more than ever," because that's not true. It always should have been this way. But now more than ever, you've got to really trust Him. Share it with the best intentions you can, for His kingdom and not for any juice for ourselves, and then see where the chips fall.
It amazes me how many times we've gotten into discussions with people and it feels like they don't know anything. Could they possibly be illiterate, driving a car and moving and grooving around us? Colleges are testifying that it's happening all over America right now.
AI, Smartphones, and a Vicious Circle
AI plays a huge part. I've seen the videos of college professors, and it's not just college. It's every level of academia, from elementary to post-secondary. These teachers and professors are absolutely frustrated because they can't get a single student to hand in a paper they wrote. It's all AI, and they know it's AI by reading it. They know the students in front of them who are turning in papers aren't actually writing them.
And yet if you're not going to pass these kids and give them degrees, how's the college going to advertise and get more students to come? It's a vicious circle, and it's dangerous, because pretty soon we're going to have doctors, lawyers, and other professional people that people's lives depend on, and they don't really know what they're doing. They're just accessing AI like you and I would. They don't know any more than you and I do.
That's really scary, because we know that:
- AI doesn't have our best interest in mind. We've talked about that on so many shows.
- AI will give different people different answers, depending on how it knows that person.
- AI will not be corrected. You can fight with it, and it's not going to give you a different answer. It's just going to say too bad, so sad.
Smartphones and electronic devices are lowering our cognitive abilities too. When we open up a book and read it, we absorb so much more than when we're googling stuff and trying to find information fast.
Goeglein says something pretty wise here: we have chosen to entertain rather than educate. We have chosen to advance political agendas in the classroom rather than teach the basic skills needed to thrive as adults. If we want to avoid the Dark Ages, the article says, we need to reexamine, reevaluate, and reverse what has caused the alarming decline in literacy. Let's encourage our young people and ourselves to pick up a book, or read one online, so we have a chance to again engage in civil, thoughtful discourse rather than cultural screaming matches.
We Already Tried, and We Failed
I'll tell you what: we already have, and we failed. Since I was old enough to know, there has been a push on television about reading. When we were young parents, it was read to your kids, read to your kids, read to your kids. The push is already there. The reevaluation has already happened, and we chose instead to post another video on TikTok and see how many more likes we could get on Facebook. That's where our significance is. The screens now, whatever they are, dominate.
The Listening Ear Versus the Reading Eye
Even audio has real strengths. If you're listening while driving a truck, walking, or working in your garden, you have a much better understanding of what's being said than if you were just watching it. That's a proven fact. I spent a couple of decades in advertising. Everybody wanted to be in TV advertising, and us lowly radio guys said, well, we'll just make your ads effective because of what happens with the ear. People imagine things. They process. They fill it in through the listening ear.
If you've never seen what a voice on the radio looks like, you've got a picture of them in your head. When we met our listeners after twenty years, back when the internet, the interwebs, was just being invented, they were largely disappointed. Emilee always had black hair and glasses, and I was always taller for some reason. The point is that the listening ear fills in blanks.
Well, what does reading a book do? It gives you so much more context, because your brain is filling it in as you read the words. How many times have you gone to a movie based on a book and heard people say the book was a lot better? Of course it was.
That's what this article is about. If we become a verbal-only society, one where you don't even have to speak the language of the country you're in, that is the mark of a return to the Dark Ages, a turn of phrase meaning a return to absolute chaos.
False Teachers and the Dopamine Hit
Doesn't this explain why people are so eager to just sit and listen to false teachers? A false teacher, just like your handheld device, gives you a dopamine hit. It makes you feel good instead of making you wrestle with a text you don't understand.
When you do wrestle with the text, you go to other resources to understand it better. After three or four different resources you say, aha, the light went on, I understand that now. No one can take that away. Maybe senility can, but no one else can take away that hard-won understanding.
Sitting and listening to some false teacher stroke your ego is a different story. You'll be so happy with that that you're never going to feel the need to crack open the Bible and wrestle with a text. Why should you, when you've got this person who's willing to tell you how great you are?
So the motivation to get people to stop reading is key. It is absolutely key. We once did a show on Bible apps, and one of the advertisements for a Bible app said it was for people who don't have time to read the Bible. That's what reading has become. (If you can find that old Bible app show, listen to it. It was the most fun I've had in three years of doing this podcast. The "laugh louder" actually came back, because we did some stuff with the Scriptures in a fun way at the end, though only those who stuck around to the end got it.)
Why Haven't They Heard It? Lessons from the Camino
We walked the Camino de Santiago, and I'll tell you what we found.
The Camino is a pilgrimage that's been going on for 1,200 years, running from basically Paris all the way to Santiago de Compostela in Spain, where the cathedral is. They believe the bones of Saint James are entombed there. It has infrastructure, and many people do it. A lot of us learned about it from the 2010 movie The Way with Martin Sheen and Emilio Estevez (it was released in 2011, I guess, after their radio tour).
I always wanted to go just to testify that Jesus paid it all, because a lot of the pilgrims who go are trying to earn their salvation. That's literally what they're doing when they lay down the burden stone at Cruz de Ferro. About 40 or 50 percent of the people walking aren't doing it for religious reasons at all. They heard there might be miracles out there. They're looking for healing. They're looking for this, they're looking for that.
I journaled 21 people and probably talked to a hundred. Every day it was about 15 miles of walking and about 15 conversations. Many of those conversations were short, but the people on the Camino are just alive, and they talk to each other. On more than one occasion I'd fall to the back and pray while the gospel was being shared. People would fall silent, and one of us would talk and talk and talk.
How many times over that 30- or 40-day journey did we hear someone say, I've never heard that before? Pretty much every day. It was amazing how many people hadn't heard the most basic gospel message. Not in context, anyway. They'd heard bits and pieces.
Why have they never heard it before? Because they've never read it.
Bits and pieces, with illiteracy added in, a little audio here and a little audio there, is going to lead to confusion and chaos inside the gospel message, and in the kingdom of Jesus Christ being advanced through the salvation of souls.
Couples Who Read and Pray Together Stay Together
Counseling is a big part of what pastors do. How many times have you asked a couple, or even an individual who came in for help, "How often do you read your Bible, by yourself or with your spouse?" And how many of them said, "We don't"?
A lot of it depends on how long they've been walking with Christ, how long they've been married, and what their journey has been. Everybody's different. But we did marriage ministry for so many years that we're talking a lot of couples. If they didn't have Christ, that was the first thing we talked about. The big question, though, was always: do you pray together?
Say we had a hundred couples (it's probably been more than that over twenty years). Ninety, ninety-two, ninety-three of them said no, we don't pray out loud together. That shocks me, because it's something we have been doing together since forever in a day.
If you don't know where to start, there are little prayers written in devotionals, like Blackaby or A. W. Tozer, where you can read the prayer out loud. A lot of it is just uncomfortability. They're not familiar with it. For guys, one of the big things is am I doing this wrong? I bet I'm doing this wrong. No. There's no wrong way. Just talk to God as your trusting Father. Talk to Jesus, through the Holy Spirit who's in you, if you're saved. Make your request known to Him, and come to Him with thanksgiving. If your bride is hearing you talk to Jesus, she's not going to judge you for doing it wrong. And if you're thinking well, you don't know my bride, you're right, I don't. But don't be afraid of that.
Couples who read together and pray together stay together. What does that say about churches? What does that say about singles who are just trying to find their way? Everybody is strengthened when they read God's Word and when they pray.
So when this Dark Ages article came up, it hit me: that is going to massively affect the gospel. And if we're headed back toward that chaos, doesn't that line up with where Jesus said in the New Testament, when I return, will I even find faith on the earth?
Comprehension Comes with Practice
It's not that people can't string together a bunch of letters to form a bunch of words. That's not what this is really about. The question is whether you can read something from beginning to end and understand what you just read. Comprehension comes with practice, and we're not practicing anymore.
We have been sounding this alarm and beating this drum for a long time about getting into God's Word and reading it. If it's hard, good. Keep reading. When you open that book, there's nothing better. Our computers are not enough. Our apps are not enough. Watching The Chosen is not enough. Even listening to Christian radio is not enough. Open up the book.
The Books Will Be Opened: Coincidence or Sign?
Here's the question. Do you think it's just a coincidence that at the end of days it says books are going to be opened, books, more than one, and we're going to find out whether our name was written in the Lamb's Book of Life?
Emilee's take: There's something very significant there. I've never thought about it before, but books have always played a significant role, not just in human history but in the Bible as well. God's Word is being preserved from the beginning of time until the end of human history, through the prophets, through the apostles, and through the teachers and preachers who hold fast to God's Word. As we see people falling into the pattern the Bible talks about, where they will no longer tolerate sound doctrine, why is that? What transforms the heart? God's Word transforms the heart. It's all connected. From the prophets until we stand before the throne of God, books are involved. They just are.
Chris's take: It's a very cool, deep observation, but I find it pretty irrelevant. The Book of Life is the biggest thing in all of human history. It's the game. Your name's in the book or your name's not in the book. Illiteracy heading toward the Dark Ages and not picking up books? I think it's a fun coincidence that the books would be opened, but it's not a sign of the times.
And I don't want anyone to misunderstand. Nobody is saying that this trend is some sort of prophetic sign about the books being opened at the end. Somebody is going to take this and come up and say, well, June 12th, Jesus is returning. All these leaps get taken with end-times eschatology. The return of illiteracy and the Dark Ages does not mean the books are about to be opened. That's all.
Even Voracious Readers Are Losing the Habit
This hits close to home. I have a library right now that's about one one-hundredth of what it used to be. We used to get books sent to us from publishers two or three a week, minimum, sometimes more. There was a time when I was reading at least a book a week, every night for a couple of hours. That ceased as technology continued to steamroll. Now I'll be lucky this year if I get twelve books in, maybe fifteen. I've since reversed the trend a little. Over the summer I had some extra time on my hands and read about six or seven books, and there are still three or four I'm working through.
One of them was a book Emilee had me read by Melissa Dougherty, Happy Lies, about New Thought, not word of faith but the New Age and NAR, and the way they manipulate people and lie to people. I didn't finish it. I got the gist of it, skimmed some, and went on to the next one.
So it's affecting even voracious readers. It's affecting everybody. You can have ChatGPT give you a summary of whatever book you want, and in five minutes you can get the gist if you were going to a book club. But it's not exercising your mind, and it's not doing the things that really help. My concern is the gospel message: people hearing it, wanting to read, wanting to write God's Word on their heart, and now they can't. Many of them can't even read. Or they're literate and they just don't want to anymore. They'd rather click on a screen.
This article gave me real pause as far as telling people, oh, get into God's Word. I realized that means something different to a different generation. When I say that, I'm assuming people will pick it up, eat it, digest it, chew on it, and absorb it. That's not necessarily what's going on anymore. We are losing the art of conversation, letter writing, and now flat-out reading.
Books That Can Help
Here are some books that can help, though none of them replaces reading God's Word.
- Happy Lies by Melissa Dougherty, for anyone who wants to go a little deeper on New Thought.
- Strange Fire by John MacArthur, if you want to see the dangers of the charismatic movement. It lays it out in an honest, easy way.
- Bible Sidekick, our offer this month. It's a 500-page book that's like combining four or five seminary classes into one volume. All 66 books of the Bible are covered, and it explains things along the way, in seventh-grade English. If you're going to read the Bible, this is the one book to go along with it.
For a gift of any amount (there's a minimum to cover the book and shipping, though some folks give $100 or $200), we can give more books away when we're out and about, and help Fresh Road Media reach more people as we gear up for 2027.
Final Thoughts
Discouragement from reading doesn't come from God. We need to return to reading, because there is no substitution for knowing what God's Word really says.
Get into God's Word again today.