Watch

Listen

Click here to listen to the episode on our website

Read

Salvaged by God Deep Dive: Hebrews 5:14

You Can Learn to Discern

Here is the good news before any of it: discernment is not a spiritual gift reserved for the elite. It is a trained skill available to every born-again believer.

Hebrews 5:14 says it plainly:

"But solid food is for the mature, for those who have their powers of discernment trained by constant practice to distinguish good from evil."

Three things jump out of that verse. First, solid food is for the mature. Second, the mature have powers of discernment, not a vague spiritual feeling, but actual powers. Third, those powers are trained by constant practice. That means you were not born with them fully formed, and you will not stumble into them accidentally. You build them.

Why Christians Seem Easily Deceived

Here is the honest answer: we are born again as infants. You get born again and you are a baby. You are not transferred in all-knowing and all-seeing. There is a reason Jesus said in John 3:7 that you must be born again, and there is a reason newborns cannot eat steak. We all start in the same place. The celebrity who finds Christ and suddenly has a million people looking to them as a Christian guru? Baby in Christ. The lifelong churchgoer who keeps falling for false teachers? May still be on milk. That is not stupidity. That is immaturity. And the answer to immaturity is growth, not shame.

The $20 illustration: Picture holding up two twenty-dollar bills, one genuine green, one a red photocopy. Offer both to a room full of people and tell them anyone over 21 can walk up and take whichever one they want. Every single time, without fail, someone eventually walks up and takes the green one. Even kids who have never had a bank account can spot it from their seat. Why? Because they have seen the real thing enough times to recognize it.

You do not train counterfeit spotters by showing them fakes. You train them by immersing them in the original until the real thing is so familiar that the counterfeit is immediately obvious. That is exactly how federal agents are trained to detect forged currency, and that is precisely how you grow in discernment. Study the word of God, not the false teaching, until the authentic is so familiar that the fake stands out.

Counterfeits are getting more sophisticated all the time. The more refined the deception, the harder it is to catch, which is exactly why we can never afford to coast. But the word of God has not changed, and the Holy Spirit who leads us into all truth (John 16:13) is still doing his job.

Four Ways Church Services Can Be Manipulative

1. Emotion-Driven Music

The data is in. Science confirms it. Music drives emotion. It evokes feeling and has real influence on the human being. Anyone who has watched a horror film knows this well. Take the music out of a horror movie and you have teenagers staring at chainsaws. Pull the audio off a music video and the whole thing suddenly looks ridiculous. Music does something powerful to us, and that is not a bad thing. That is actually a wonderful thing, when it is used rightly.

A genuine caveat: Worship music is outstanding. Many believers still prefer the old hymns, and it is remarkable how congregations often sing louder on the hymns than on anything else. A well-crafted Phil Wickham or Chris Tomlin song, led by a praise team that genuinely loves the Lord and is leading people to worship, is a righteous thing. Nothing in this section should be read otherwise.

The test: Next time you are in a service singing songs, strip everything away. Take away the atmosphere, the instrumentation, the emotional swell of a room full of people with raised hands. Read the lyrics as plain text on a page and ask: does this hold up? Are these words theologically grounded? Do they point you toward God, or do they point you toward a warm and positive version of yourself?

That is the dividing line. Worship music that moves you toward God through truth is a righteous thing. Music engineered to generate an emotional experience and then let that experience do the work of the Holy Spirit is manipulation.

On the bigger picture of worship: Praise music is actually one part of a much larger whole. Communion is worship. Prayer is worship. The offering is worship. Preaching the word is worship. Our whole lives are to be a life of worship (Romans 12:1). The music, the praise portion, is designed to help people enter the courts with thanksgiving (Psalm 100:4), to prepare their hearts for everything that follows. That movement of the heart is not a bad thing in itself. But if the emotional movement is the thrust of the entire service, that is a warning sign. You are likely being filled up with bread before the steak ever arrives.

A practical word for preachers: The conviction of the Holy Spirit does not need a guitar. When music quietly builds underneath a prayer or an altar call, the honest question is this: why? The Spirit does not need the assist. If the truth of God's word is not carrying the weight on its own, the answer is not a better soundtrack. It is better execution of the text. As Romans 1:16 reminds us, the gospel itself is the power of God for salvation. It works in spite of the speaker, not because of them.

Billy Graham used Just as I Am at his crusades. That is a fine example of music used appropriately. The song is theologically rich, and it gave space for people who had already been confronted with the gospel to make their way forward. But that is categorically different from using music as the engine of a decision, getting people emotionally ready to respond before the gospel has even been clearly presented.

Almost every so-called revival in recent memory has been built almost entirely on music and emotion, and almost every one has produced a wave of shallow or false conversions. A year later, two years later, three years later, people are gone. They had an emotional experience and mistook it for regeneration.

Real conversion looks like this: the word is preached, the Holy Spirit convicts the sinner (John 16:8), the sinner recognizes themselves as someone under the wrath of God (Romans 3:23), they see that Jesus took that wrath upon himself on the cross (Romans 5:8), and they repent and call on his name (Romans 10:13). That is a categorically different reality than singing emotionally charged songs until someone feels saved.

Feelings and "follow my heart" are the twin engines of false conversion. And the stakes could not be higher. Jesus himself described two groups in Matthew 13:42 and 8:12: weepers and gnashers. These are not the same people. The weepers know they were offered the free gift and did not take it. The gnashers are furious because they believed they had the real thing and did not. That is the most heart-wrenching reality in all of Christianity, and it is precisely why eliminating manipulation is not legalism. It is love.

2. Beware the Con

Watch enough true-crime documentaries. Watch enough fraud exposés. A pattern emerges every single time: the victim looks back at the story they were made to believe and cannot understand how they fell for it. Because if you had simply walked up to them on day one and presented the conclusion cold, they would have rejected it immediately. They would have known it was wrong.

But that is not how the con works. The con works by layering. Story upon story. Experience upon experience. Each one reasonable. Each one building on the last. A verse sprinkled in here, a personal testimony there. Slowly, rung by rung, you have been walked up a ladder, and by the time you reach the top, the jump feels like the most natural thing in the world.

That is exactly what is happening in pulpits across the country right now.

Watch the high-following preachers on YouTube, on broadcast television, in large church environments. They get up and they tell stories: about themselves, about someone they know, about something God supposedly revealed to them. And then they glance at a verse or two along the way. Somehow that is supposed to constitute preaching the word. It is not. That is a con.

A fair caveat: There are four legitimate forms of preaching:

• Verse-by-verse expository preaching is the gold standard. You exegete the text, draw out the meaning, and apply what it says (2 Timothy 4:2).
• Topical series done faithfully have their place, covering a subject through multiple scriptures.
• Textual preaching works through a narrative chunk of scripture, such as walking through the life of Abraham from his call (Genesis 12) to the ram in the thicket (Genesis 22) in a single message.
• Storytelling can be legitimate when it has genuine scriptural backing and the text is doing the actual work.

The difference is proportion. Illustrations from real life are good. A personal story told with self-deprecating honesty that directs people toward Jesus and not toward the speaker is fine. But stories should be a minor part of the message, a small supporting element, never the structure. The text must be the structure. When stories become the vehicle and scripture becomes the occasional decorative verse, people are being entertained, not fed. A congregation that gets entertained every week without being fed stays spiritually malnourished and wide open to whatever the next compelling voice tells them.

The deeper issue with experience-based preaching: even your own experiences can be deceptive. You thought something was one thing and it turned out to be another. Experiences feel true. They feel authoritative. But you cannot trust your experiences above the word of God, because experiences can be wrong and the word cannot (Psalm 119:89). The moment a teacher positions themselves as having special revelation above what you can find and verify in your Bible, Galatians 1:8 applies. Run.

A TED talk with a Bible sprinkled in is not preaching. It is not feeding. And it is producing some of the weakest Christian formation in generations.

3. The Twisting of Scripture

This is the one that requires the most maturity to catch, and where the most long-term spiritual damage gets done quietly, over time, in people who believe they are being fed.

Scripture twisting can be as subtle as a single word. One preposition changed from in to on can shift the entire meaning of a verse. You would never catch it if you did not know the text yourself. That is precisely the point.

This is why it matters that pastors open the word and read the text, not quote from memory, not paraphrase their way around it, not deliver a dramatic retelling. When the Bible is open in front of both speaker and congregation, manipulation becomes harder. You can follow along. You can compare translations. You can ask whether what is being said about those words is actually true.

The real and lasting solution is knowing the word for yourself.

Memorize scripture. Yes, it sounds like 1960s Sunday school. It is. And it is tried and true. Ambrose set scripture to music for exactly this reason, so that people could carry the text in their own memory and not be permanently dependent on someone else to interpret it for them. The method was good then, and it is still good now.

Be like the Bereans. When the apostle Paul came to Berea with the gospel, the people there did not simply accept his word because of who he was or what he claimed. Acts 17:11 records that they examined the scriptures every day to see if what he was saying was true. And they were commended for that, not criticized, not called suspicious. If the Bereans were right to fact-check an apostle, how much more should we be fact-checking whoever stands behind any pulpit today?

A word on eisegesis vs. exegesis: When Jesus sent out the twelve disciples (Matthew 10:1-15), there are teachers who say this passage gives those gifts and that authority to believers today. Nothing in the text says that. Jesus handpicked those twelve as eyewitnesses to himself, and there were witnesses to the handpicking. When someone shows up today claiming apostolic authority, the question is simple: what is your verification? The scripture places apostles and prophets as the foundation of the church (Ephesians 2:20), a foundation that has already been laid.

A note on translation: The English language creates problems that the original languages do not have. In Luke 14:26, Jesus says you cannot be his disciple unless you hate your family. Take that English word at face value and it appears to contradict Matthew 22:39 (love your neighbor) and Exodus 20:12 (honor your father and mother). But the Greek word used there carries a meaning closer to that which must always remain second. In Genesis 29:31, it says Jacob hated Leah. He did not despise her. She was simply always going to be second to Rachel. The same dynamic applies to Jacob and Esau (Malachi 1:2-3, Romans 9:13). Jesus is saying: if anything in your life ranks above him, you cannot be his disciple. Everything else must remain secondary by comparison. When you understand the original language and cultural context, the text opens up. When you do not, you are at the mercy of whoever is behind the pulpit.

One more framework: the scriptures were not written to us. They were written for us (Romans 15:4, 1 Corinthians 10:11). That distinction changes everything about how you read them. Every passage has an original audience, an original context, and an original meaning. Who were they talking to? Why were they saying it? What would those words have meant to the people who first received them? When you start there, it becomes much harder for a teacher to drop you into the text as the protagonist of a story that was never about you.

4. Repetitive Words and Manufactured Agreement

This one often shows up hand-in-hand with everything else already covered.

There is a manipulation tactic built around repetitive words and phrases, not to teach, not to help scripture stick, but to walk a congregation down a predetermined path by training them to say yes. And the path almost always leads somewhere far from good spiritual food.

Legitimate repetition exists and is worth distinguishing. A pastor having a congregation repeat a word like propitiation two or three times to help it stick in memory (see Romans 3:25) is good teaching. Inviting the occasional amen as part of natural communication is totally fine.

The manipulative version sounds like this: Everybody say "faith." Faith. Say it again. Faith. Now say "hope." Hope. Over and over, with no theological content underneath it, no text being executed, nothing but the repeated exercise of getting a crowd to respond on cue. The congregation is being slowly habituated to follow the speaker's prompts, and if you look at the rest of the service when this is happening, almost guaranteed, music has quietly started underneath the speaker. The emotional scaffolding is going up piece by piece.

This is the pablum path. It is the spiritual equivalent of going to a steakhouse and getting an enormous loaf of bread dropped on the table. The bread is not bad. But if you keep eating it, you will be too full to touch the steak when it arrives, and that is exactly the point. Fill people up with warm feelings, repeated affirmations, manufactured group agreement, and emotional momentum, and they will leave feeling great. They will feel fed. And they will not notice until much later, if ever, that they did not actually receive anything of substance.

The question for any sermon, any service, any preacher is never: how good was the performance? Never: how many people responded? The only question that matters is: did people receive good spiritual food? Was Jesus exalted (John 12:32)? Were sinners confronted with their need for a Savior and pointed clearly to the one who meets it? Were those who are nominally Christian shown the difference between merely believing and actually following Jesus as a disciple (Matthew 16:24)?

That is the steak. Everything else is bread.

A Case Study in Manipulation: Robert Morris and the Press Conference

Hours after being released from Osage County Jail in Oklahoma, following six months of a sentence for the sexual abuse of a woman named Cindy, abuse that began when he was 21 and she was only 12 years old and continued for years, Gateway Church founder Robert Morris held a press conference.

Not a private conversation. Not a quiet letter. A press conference. Hours after walking out of jail.

Watch the mechanics of this carefully, because this is manipulation 101, and it follows the exact same layering we have been talking about throughout this article.

First layer: Cindy already forgave him. Publicly. When this first came to light, she was already on record that she and her family had forgiven him and were moving forward in the love of Jesus. That forgiveness had already been given and received. So the question is not whether forgiveness is right. It is (Colossians 3:13). The question is: why are we at a press conference?

Second layer: His statement made specific mention that Cindy's father had already extended grace to him. He is building the ladder deliberately. Her father forgave him. She already forgave him. He is asking publicly for her forgiveness again. And now the entire audience who watched that press conference is standing under the implied question: are you going to forgive him? Are you going to be the kind of Christian who extends grace?

That is the card. It is the card that takes a genuine biblical command (forgiveness) and uses it to bypass a separate and equally clear biblical command (qualification for ministry, as outlined in 1 Timothy 3:2 and Titus 1:6-9). It frames anyone who says he should not return to a pulpit as unforgiving and unChristlike. That is not a spiritual question at that point. That is a trap.

Third layer: This shot was called before he was even removed. The way these situations play out has been seen many times before. As soon as the sentence is served, as soon as enough time has passed, the narrative begins to be constructed that leads back to the platform. A press conference hours after release is not the conclusion of this story. It is the opening move.

On Forgiveness and Disqualification

Let this be absolutely clear: forgiveness and restoration to ministry are not the same thing. They have never been the same thing. They do not become the same thing because someone uses the language of Christianity skillfully.

Robert Morris is not beyond the forgiveness of God. Nobody is (1 John 1:9). Every authentic born-again believer should extend to him the right hand of fellowship as a brother in Christ. We should genuinely hope and pray that he walks faithfully with Jesus for the rest of his days. We should want full healing and justice for Cindy and her family.

And Robert Morris can never be a pastor again. Full stop.

This is not a harsh position. It is not an unforgiving spirit. It is the recognition that 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 establish qualifications for pastoral ministry precisely because the role of a pastor involves a level of trust and authority over people's spiritual lives. Scripture is clear: an overseer must be above reproach.

Consider how we handle this in every other sphere of trust and responsibility. A doctor who commits malpractice loses their license. Not because we hate them, but because patients must be protected. A lawyer who betrays clients gets disbarred. A coach who abuses athletes never coaches again. We accept these outcomes without debate in every professional context.

A pastor deals in matters of eternal life and death. He stands before people at their most vulnerable, in their grief, their doubt, their searching, their spiritual infancy, and holds a position of authority over their souls. The standard cannot be lower than a doctor or a lawyer. When you have bitten the sheep, you do not get to protect the sheep anymore. That is not unforgiveness. That is stewardship of the flock (1 Peter 5:2-3).

Here is the tell. When you get out of jail, you should have an audience of one. Go home. Get before the Lord. Ask what faithful, quiet, obscure service to the kingdom looks like for the rest of your life, not what the pathway back to significance looks like. The only thing that is lacking is the platform, the following, the significance of being a spiritual leader with massive reach. A press conference hours after release is not the behavior of a man who has genuinely reckoned with the permanent loss of that.

If this is not a play, Robert Morris will quietly disappear from the Christian limelight. No more press conferences. No public statements positioning a comeback. No book about what he learned. Just a man walking humbly before his God (Micah 6:8), grateful for forgiveness, bearing the permanent and appropriate consequence of disqualification.

Watch and see. The answer will be obvious.

And this is why discernment matters. Not as an exercise in cynicism. Not as a reason to distrust every pastor or abandon the local church. But because the bride of Christ deserves protection (Ephesians 5:25-27), and right now, across the visible church, too many wolves are being handed back the shepherd's staff by people who confused forgiveness with reinstatement.

Final Thoughts

Four ways church services can manipulate you. Emotion-driven music above and beyond what appropriately makes the name of Jesus great. The con, stories and experiences stacked up to walk you away from the scriptures one rung at a time. The twisting of God's word, bending the text to serve a conclusion somebody already reached. And repetitive words designed to manufacture agreement and fill you up with bread when your soul needs meat.

These are not obscure tactics used only by fringe groups. They are operating in mainstream evangelical churches, in the biggest broadcasts, in the services with the most impressive followings. And the reason Christians keep falling for them is not stupidity. It is immaturity. It is milk when we need meat. It is a red copy looking convincing enough because we have not handled the real thing enough times to recognize the difference immediately.

The answer is not complicated, even when it is hard.

Get into the word. Memorize scripture. Go home after the service and open the passage that was preached and read it yourself. Check the original language. Compare translations. Be a Berean (Acts 17:11), not because you distrust your pastor, but because you love the truth enough to verify it. Let constant practice train your powers of discernment until the counterfeit stands out the way a red photocopy stands out next to a genuine bill.

"But solid food is for the mature, for those who have their powers of discernment trained by constant practice to distinguish good from evil." (Hebrews 5:14)

Solid food is for the mature. And the mature did not arrive there by accident. They practiced, every single day, in prayer and in the word, until distinguishing good from evil became second nature.

Get into the word today. Go and serve your King.